Main Content






Start Finding

Meet Carrie Abfall
With a great sense of humor, expertise, and unwavering integrity, Carrie has been a part of the Columbus and Central Indiana real estate market for over 30 years. Many of her clients today are repeat and send her referrals of their friends and family.
Throughout her full time career in real estate Carrie has had the privilege of guiding clients through one of the most important journeys– buying or selling and many times both! Carrie’s approach is simple yet effective to achieve the desired results and ensure a seamless experience for every client. She understands the nuances of the Indiana market and is here to provide expert guidance every step of the way.
Why Work With RE/MAX
Volume
Riley Children's Hospital
Real Estate Professional

Real Stories From Satisfied Clients

As a buyer, I felt comfortable being honest with Carrie as we toured homes. She is smart and you can tell she really cares about you. She always came prepared and had the disclosures and the land map and the information so that when we went to see the houses, she knew everything about them. When I f...
As a seasoned buyer I had always worked with a friend of my moms, and then I met Carrie at an open house. Immediately I was like, wait… Realtors do that for you and they run comps and stats and help you strategize? There are tons of realtors who open doors and say this is the kitchen…do not ...
Carrie is amazing and goes above and beyond! She knows her stuff and always has your back. Super quick to respond, kept me constantly informed. And we had some drama with an old fireplace that she handled skillfully. After two other realtors I finally got to see how it should be done!!!
Carrie is the BEST! She helped sell our house for top dollar and negotiated $50k off the price of our new home. She understood who the potential buyer was for our home and helped us pre prep to make the house shine And her expert advice on timing, really helped us make good decisions. She is ou...
We loved having Carrie as our realtor! She answered all my questions - even the ones I would think of late in the night, she was there with a quick response. I felt confident in her work and I had 100% trust in her. She went beyond the call and sold our home in no time! I will recommend Carrie to an...
Carrie helped us to purchase a new home and sell our previous home within a 1–2-week period. It was an amazing experience working with her. You absolutely have to follow her recommendations exactly and things will go smoothly. She got us a great deal on our new home and helped us to sell our previ...
Carrie helped us sell our home that was on the market for 6 months with another agent without an offer – and although we did lower the price, she staged it and had photos taken that were so much different and better. She was the only agent who had the guts to tell us a “get it sold” price, whi...
Carrie is awesome! She was honest, helpful, and dedicated. We were able to sell my Mom’s house quickly and it wasn’t in the best shape. I wouldn’t hesitate working with her again, and I highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell in Columbus.

to buy?
I can help you navigate the journey with my
Free Buyers Guide

to sell?
My Free Sellers Guide can help you with what you need to know before jumping in


current value of
your property?
Get a free home valuation with the latest information.